Categories
Game Development

Just Adobe Being Adobe

This week I dealt with an issue that made me want to write about the times software has proven me wrong in some way, either to make me realize it was better than I thought, or (perhaps more often) the other way around. Sometimes, this broken trust isn’t the fault of the developer. Big corporations buying things usually spells dystopian doom for a good product, and I’ve come to expect that. When companies like Microsoft or Adobe get involved, maybe it’s just time to leave. And on the other side of the table, sometimes it’s worth giving smaller players you never considered before a chance. They may truly impress you. (And then, of course, you just hope they don’t become yet another company absorbed by one of the tech giants)

In this post, I’m going to write about the issue in question, but in future posts I’d like to write about some other (hopefully more positive) stories.

Substance

A few years back, I found a piece of software called Substance Painter, which I eagerly included into my 3D workflow, because it truly is an excellent texture painting program. I also picked up the companion program Substance Designer at the time, and I purchased both of them via Steam. I appreciated the fact that you could sign up on their website, link your steam account, and download a standalone copy of their software, with a perpetual license for that version. As nice as it can be to install software via Steam, sometimes it’s nice to be able to minimize distractions, and there’s also the notorious issue that steam will only allow you to have any game or software open on one computer at a time (even free software, strangely). As such, this standalone version was pretty important to me.

And as great of software as Substance made, I’m here to explain how Adobe instantly erased all of the good will that the developers of Substance built over the years.

If you know anything about Adobe, you probably wonder why I even made the mistake of trusting any of their software to remain reasonably priced. And the answer to that is that I, unfortunately, gave them the benefit of the doubt. I’ve since learned my lesson.

2021 Edition Lies

This year, Adobe released the 2021 edition of Substance, and I actually pre-ordered it because I had owned both the 2019 and 2020 editions previously, and I really liked it. I figured 2021 would bring only good things for Substance. A bit wary of Adobe, I double checked the community posts to confirm that the 2021 edition would still offer a standalone version. Everybody said it would.

January 28th rolled around and as before, I tried to sync my Steam account to update my standalone perpetual licenses to include 2021. Only this time their site threw errors and wouldn’t let me update the license. No big deal, release days often have bugs like this. I’d check back later on to update my license.

A few days into March I decided to check back, and the site was still giving the same unhelpful error, telling me I had no products to sync. This time I emailed Substance, and here’s the conversation:

Hi, I purchased the 2021 editions of both Substance Painter and Designer on Steam at the end of last year, and they’ve been working great through steam, however I haven’t been able to get the standalone licenses working. Looking in my account (under same email as I’m sending from) when I attempt to sync the licenses from Steam, I get a message saying “Could not find any product to sync”, and the end-of-maintenance date does not update on the licenses I have. My profile is set to public, and I do have both of those in my library. Is there anything you guys can do from your end to help me get this working? Thanks for the help, and let me know if you need any additional information.

Also FYI, I’m emailing directly instead of using the contact form on the site because it looks like I can’t submit the form after filling it out. It scrolls part way up the page as if it was indicating a form validation error, but there’s no error messages visible, and all of the fields are filled out, so I’m not really sure what that issue is about either. I’m using the latest stable version of Firefox if that helps. Thanks again!

Me

Hi Alex, Thanks for reaching out but unfortunately since the end of February you are no longer able to sync your Steam license to your Substance profile. The page will remain up for a few weeks while our web team disables the backend feature. I apologize for the confusion.

Jeffrey – Customer Success Manager

First of all, it seems like their web team is woefully understaffed. Not only has their contact form been broken for months, but they couldn’t even coordinate the removal of the button to sync your steam account? And the explanation is a little odd. Why can’t a frontend button be removed before a backend feature? And given the error, it would appear the backend feature has been disabled for at least a couple of months now. If I was willing to dig in deeper I might call shenanigans and say that the presence of that button has been a deliberate attempt to deceive existing users into thinking their licenses would continue being supported. But I digress.

At this point I was a bit concerned. But since I purchased the software in December, I figured, like every other software company I’d ever dealt with before, they’d be willing to honor the license at the time of purchase. So that’s what I asked for.

Okay, no worries. Is there not another way to get a standalone license for this product without purchasing a second license on the website? I purchased this via steam under the expectation that I would be able to do that as I have in the past. If that isn’t the case, I would have purchased the stand alone license instead of the steam one. Also to note, I did purchase this in December and attempted to sync in January, so if this is a recent change, I feel I ought to still be eligible for the license as it was at the time I purchased it. Thanks again for the help!

Me

Hi Alex, The only way to obtain a perpetual license is via Steam. I apologize but since the end of February we can no longer manually sync them internally either as that system has not been disabled.

Jeffrey – Customer Success Manager

Getting some repetitive answers by now, and it’s also become abundantly obvious that they have no intention of helping me at all. Since their website has literally been broken for months though, I figure, perhaps they just need to catch up before bringing the functionality back in the future.

Is there any chance of seeing perpetual licenses (standalone, not via steam) return in the future, or does this mean Substance is moving to subscription-only going forward?

Me

Alex, Substance will be subscription based moving forward.

Jeffrey – Customer Success Manager

Ah, good old Adobe. I should have known what to expect. I gave them the benefit of the doubt, and I regret that so much. So what I’ve got so far is: (1) Adobe will not honor the license I had at the time of purchase, and instead they are revoking access to software that I paid for, and (2) the software cannot be purchased ever again, as it will only be available on a rental basis. Again, this is expected behavior from Adobe. This is how all of their software works. What I didn’t expect from Adobe, however, was the blatant willingness to spit in their customers faces shortly after releasing a new version. I expected to have my 2021 license honored, and the 2022 edition would introduce a new licensing scheme. But in the end Adobe had more contempt for their customers than I had ever expected.

And so at this point I gave up. I figured I’d let the guy know how I felt, and try to move on.

Fair enough. I’m not really surprised, I just never expected this to happen in such a way as to leave us high and dry immediately after preordering an upgrade. It’s super disappointing. What can I do to get a refund for my purchase?

Me

Alexander, In this case since the purchase was made on Steam you will need to contact them immediately to advise if a refund is eligible for the product. Cheers,

Jeffrey – Customer Success Manager

Of course. By all means don’t go out of your way to help me. Just tell me to deal with another company. Well despite the fact that I literally have a combined total of 4 minutes of time on both of these apps in steam, when I pleaded by case and requested a refund, they of course rejected it, because it’s been more than two weeks since I purchased it. I’m 100% certain that they could grant my refund themselves, as I’ve seen other developers do. But unlike most indie developers, Adobe represents all of the worst parts of the software industry, and you can damn well count on them to do nothing to help you out when it comes down to it.

And that will, without a doubt, be the last time I make the mistake of trusting Adobe.

Moving On

Oh well, if I can’t get a refund, at least I’ve got some decent texture painting software to use in the future, right?

Well of course, the problem with that comes down to standardization. In making assets for games, I like the files generated by my workflow to be files that I can continue to rely on in the future, and continue to iterate with. But seeing as I know I will never own another edition of Substance in the future, it makes little sense to make anything with it now, knowing that I will just be using other tools down the line.

And for those wanting some recommendations to replace Substance in your own workflows (and probably for the same reason), there’s some amazing software out there.

For one, Blender has decent texture painting built in. If you want to upgrade the texture painting functionality to be on par with Substance (and all without having to leave your modeling software!) you can purchase BPainter for a fraction of the cost of Substance. And you’ll be supporting a developer who actually stands behind their product. And, if you prefer a standalone tool, you can buy ArmorPaint, once again for a fraction of the cost, and you’ll be supporting open source software.

TL;DR

For me personally, the Blender/BPainter combo will be my main workflow going forward. You should do whatever works for you, all I ask is that you please, please stop supporting companies like Adobe. Substance is a good piece of software, but I wouldn’t recommend any individual developers rely on it anymore. It now exists more in the space of rental-only corporate-targeted software that exists as an industry standard solely because larger studios have bottomless pockets and prefer to throw money at problems than find creative solutions. And that type of software is precisely what Adobe does best.

Spread the love

By Alexander Barber

Ráðum’k þér, Loddfáfnir,
at þú ráð nemir,
njóta mundu ef þú nemr,
þér munu góð ef þú getr:
Góðan mann
teygðu þér at gamanrúnum,
ok nem líknargaldr meðan þú lifir.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *